The deep layer · what was written
Voyage and Return (Booker): the entry
Definition
Voyage and Return is the fourth of the seven plots in Christopher Booker’s The Seven Basic Plots (2004). It is a plot, not an archetype and not a character. The name describes the shape of a whole story. The hero or heroine, often young, bored or heedless, falls out of the ordinary world into another one: down a rabbit hole, through a wardrobe, across the sea to an island, forward in time, or into an unfamiliar class or country. At first the new world fascinates. Then its strangeness turns to threat, the threat grows until it seems there is no way out, and at the last moment the hero escapes and returns home.
Booker sets the plot out in five named stages: an Anticipation Stage and the “fall” into the other world; an Initial Fascination or Dream Stage; a Frustration Stage; a Nightmare Stage; and the Thrilling Escape and Return. Unlike the Quest, the journey has no goal. What matters, for Booker, is what the hero brings back. Some return enlightened, some merely chastened, and in his dark versions the hero fails the test and comes home no wiser, or emptier. Within his Jungian frame the other world tests the limits of the hero’s awareness, and Booker gives Part One, where all seven plots are set out, the title “The Seven Gateways to the Underworld”. That reading is his frame, not a finding.
History
Booker published the book in London with Continuum in November 2004; an American edition followed in 2005, the paperback was later reprinted under the Bloomsbury imprint, and a twentieth-anniversary edition with a preface by Nicholas Booker appeared in 2024. Voyage and Return is chapter 5 of Part One.
It is also the plot Booker uses, in his Prologue, to show how the idea of basic plots came to him (p. 5). He describes a list of stories that seemed to have nothing in common, children’s classics such as Peter Rabbit, Peter Pan and Alice in Wonderland, novels from Robinson Crusoe to Brideshead Revisited, Wells’s The Time Machine, and films from The Third Man to Gone With the Wind, until, as he puts it, the penny dropped that they shared one shape.
The chapter’s examples, checked against the text of the paperback reprint, run from the nursery to the novel. Alice (pp. 87–88, 96–98) is the type case; Goldilocks and Peter Rabbit (pp. 87, 89) are the smallest, each ending in a thrilling escape back to home and mother. Peter Pan (pp. 88–89) and C. S. Lewis’s The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (pp. 88, 97) are journeys into an imaginary world. Robinson Crusoe (pp. 90, 100–102), Gulliver’s Travels (pp. 90–91), Johnson’s Rasselas and Voltaire’s Candide (pp. 91n, 96, 99), and The Time Machine (pp. 92, 96, 103) send their heroes abroad or out of time; Coleridge’s Rime of the Ancient Mariner is the haunting case of a return with hard-won understanding. A “social” Voyage and Return drops the hero into an unfamiliar milieu: The Third Man (pp. 94, 103) and Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (pp. 93, 96, 98, 103). Orpheus and Eurydice (pp. 103–104), whose hero comes back from the underworld alone and loveless, comes near the end of the chapter as the dark version. In Part Three Booker returns to Brideshead and Gone with the Wind (p. 396) as lesser dark versions.
Booker takes the pattern from the stories and its meaning from Jung. The pattern is old, but some of his cases answer one another rather than arising independently: Gulliver’s Travels, which Booker notes appeared seven years after Robinson Crusoe, belongs to the same vogue for voyages to strange lands. The five stages, the name as one of seven plots and the Jungian reading are Booker’s, dated 2004.
The debate
What kind of thing is it? In the void the plot sits nearest the hero and the child, since so many of its travellers are children and its happy form ends in a return home. It is neither figure. It is a plot, a sequence of stages, and the site lists the seven as plots by the editor’s decision. The nearest Jungian idea is not a personified archetype at all but the descent into another world and the return, a motif Jung discussed among his archetypes of transformation (see rebirth); Booker’s plot gives that motif a fixed five-stage course and a moral test, which are his own.
The reviewers’ general objections apply here with some force. Michiko Kakutani (2005) used the plot to illustrate the book’s appeal, asking what Peter Rabbit, Scarlett O’Hara and Alice could have in common, and conceded that Booker does a nimble job of collating parallels. Kasia Boddy (2004) argued that his claim to universality would have been stronger with non-Western examples, and that influence between writers explains much of what he attributes to the unconscious. Publishers Weekly (2005) and Adam Mars-Jones (2004) both noted errors in his treatment of film; one small instance is in this chapter, where The Third Man is dated 1948, a year before its release.
Empirical status
None. No study has tested Voyage and Return as a category that texts or readers actually sort into. Reagan and colleagues (2016), who classified the emotional arcs of 1,327 Project Gutenberg works into six shapes, cite Booker and give The Time Machine as his example of this plot, but state that an emotional arc is not a plot, so their result neither supports nor refutes his scheme.
Appearances
In writing advice the plot is usually illustrated with The Hobbit. Jericho Writers’ guide to the seven plots uses Bilbo’s journey out of the Shire, with the threats growing worse until the turnabout and the return home braver. Shmoop’s study guides file works such as The Tempest, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and Lord of the Flies under the plot. Some popular summaries list The Lion King and Back to the Future; Booker does not place either here, and discusses The Lion King elsewhere as a story of a boy who becomes king (pp. 285–287). These are later readings in his scheme, not his examples.
Sources
- Booker, C. (2004). The Seven Basic Plots: Why We Tell Stories. London: Continuum. ISBN 978-0-8264-5209-2. Prologue to Part One; Part One, ch. 5, “Voyage and Return”; Part Three, ch. 23.
- Booker, C. (2004/2013). The Seven Basic Plots (paperback reprint, Bloomsbury). ISBN 978-0-8264-8037-8. Page numbers above are from this printing, checked in the Internet Archive copy: https://archive.org/details/sevenbasicplotsw0000book_v4w4
- Booker, C. (2024). The Seven Basic Plots (20th anniversary edition, preface by Nicholas Booker). Bloomsbury. ISBN 978-1-3994-1592-7. Chapter 5: https://doi.org/10.5040/9781399417440.ch-05
- Mars-Jones, A. (2004, 21 November). Terminator 2 good, The Odyssey bad. The Observer. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2004/nov/21/fiction.features
- Boddy, K. (2004, 21 November). Everything ever written boiled down to seven plots. The Telegraph. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/3632074/Everything-ever-written-boiled-down-to-seven-plots.html
- Publishers Weekly (2005, 14 February). Review of The Seven Basic Plots. https://www.publishersweekly.com/9780826452092
- Kakutani, M. (2005, 15 April). The plot thins, or are no stories new? The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/15/books/15book.html
- Reagan, A. J., Mitchell, L., Kiley, D., Danforth, C. M., & Dodds, P. S. (2016). The emotional arcs of stories are dominated by six basic shapes. EPJ Data Science, 5, 31. https://doi.org/10.1140/epjds/s13688-016-0093-1 (appendix A, arXiv:1606.07772)
- Jericho Writers. How to write seven basic plots. https://jerichowriters.com/how-to-write-seven-basic-plots/
- Shmoop. The Tempest: Booker’s Seven Basic Plots Analysis. https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/the-tempest/voyage-return-plot.html